| Platinum | House of Pizza Division St |
| Gold | Uncle Tony's Pizza & Pasta East Providence |
| Silver | Tony's Pizza Palace Pawtucket |
| Bronze | Pawtucket House of Pizza |
| Top Pick | A Guy and His Pie |
| Top Pick | Arigna Irish Pub & Coal Fire Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Flatbread Pizza Company |
| Top Pick | Natalie's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Olly's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Village Pizza |